Raeanne:
“A human being fashions
his consequences as surely as he fashions his goods or his dwelling
his goods or his dwelling. Nothing that he says, thinks or does is
without consequences.” -Norman Cousins. Raeanne
lives her life day by day not once thinking about the consequences of
her actions of the effects that they have on the people around her.
In the novel Identical
by Ellen Hopkins Raeanne
chooses to have sex with not one, but three guys. Raeanne yearns to
be loved, she wants to be loved in a more emotional sense than she'd
like to admit because she can't survive on just physical love.
Physical love doesn't truly exist without there being a sense of
emotional love. I don't think that Raeanne understands that and she
can't keep on living the way she does, throwing caution to the wind
without a thought to her future.
The
first guy she has sex with, Mick, she is mostly using for access to
drugs but also so she can feel in control. The second guy, Ty, she
uses to get any sort of feeling and to get back at Mick for flirting
with Madison. “But getting of myself isn't the best part. I do
everything in my power to make sure he gets off. And that puts me
indisputably in control. (He thinks otherwise, and I let him.) It's
the only time I am in control. And I like how that feel most of all.”
pg 28. The third is her history teacher Mr.Lawler, with him I think
that Raeanne finally realizes that she can't live off physical love
and she really believes she's in love with him, no matter how immoral
it is. Raeanne wants to be loved and to feel that she can be loved,
she cares deeply about her sister Kaeleigh even though she is
insanely jealous of her and her relationship with their father (which
Kaeleigh loathes). “Kaeleigh
closes herself off from Daddy. And I think she's completely insane, I
crave his affection... why would my father be so taken with her but
distance himself from me?”
pg 19. Others view Raeanne as a slut, loser, stoner, and an easy to
get vamp. Raeanne's only motivation it seems is to protect her sister
and to be more like her sister so that her father will love her the
same way he loves Kaeleigh, “The
only person I want to be close to is Daddy, and he doesn't even see
me.”
pg 21. Raeanne views herself as fat, unlovable, usable, and
disposable even though she acts all tough on the outside at school,
and at home. “I'm
strong.... a survivor... I can't... understand,... why I... crumble?”
pg 46. Madison, Micks ex girlfriend, always seems to be sticking her
nose where it doesn't belong and getting in the way, of Kaeleigh and
Ian's almost-there-but-not-quite-relationship and Raeanne and Micks
conflicted relationship, “Could
be why she's hustling Mick now. When he was up for grabs, she
couldn't care less about scratching his figurative itch. All it took
was hooking up with me and out came her stubby little claws.”
pg 38-39. As bad as Raeanne seems she does have some redeeming
qualities. Even though the reasons for caring for her sister may be a
little misplaced, she still cares deeply for her and would do almost
anything to protect her, from the outside world and all its dangers
as well as all the dangers in their own little world at home. If
Raeanne had someone to teach her about love, not the warped love that
her father taught her and her sister, but real love, family love,
physical love, then she'd be able to change her ways and see that
living life day by day can have some serious consequences.
Kaeleigh:
“Inner
demons, inner war./ I'm in the middle of it all./ Pulling myself
together,/ Knowing all I'll do is fall.” -Author Unknown. Kaeleigh
has to try to fight her inner demons day by day and struggles to find
a reason to keep fighting. In the novel Identical
Kaeleigh
is faced with many hard choices throughout the novel, one of them
being whether she should let Ian love her and if she can love him
back. Because Kaeleigh was raped by her father, every time she lets
someone get close to her - whether a physical or emotional connection
- she has to fight the urge to run and hide, and push away the
thoughts of pain from her past. If Kaeleigh could love anyone she
would be fine, and could live a normal life; if she could forget her
past and her father she could be a normal teenager. Kaeleigh yearns
for love, not the physical kind because that much has been taken away
from her by her father, but the emotional kind where she can really
connect with someone. I think that without help from a professional
or being able to open up to Ian or even to a friend she'll never be
able to change or love anyone.
Kaeleigh
wants very much to love Ian, and deep down she does and she knows it
she just doesn't know if she can because of her father and the images
that bombard her when she gets close to letting him in. “And
I kissed him back, but only for a second because suddenly all I could
see was a featureless face, with a wide, sour mouth coaxing,
'Please,
baby. I won't hurt you.'
Fear enveloped me, clasped itself around me. I couldn't shake free,
struggled to find breath.” pg
35. She's afraid that her father will never let her out of his grip
and she'll have to stay there forever. She's afraid that if she
doesn't fight her inner demons and win then one day she'll just
implode and no one will be there to clean up the mess, she'll just be
left all alone to pick up the pieces of herself that everyone has
walked all over. Raeanne and her family view Kaeleigh as a
goody-goody, spineless little girl, “She's
soft. Pliable. Gullible.” pg
20, but the people at school view her as basically the normal popular
girl, “Call
me powerless yeah, I know on a first glance I have it all. Looks.
Money. Straight As. Leads. Popularity...” pg
29 Kaeleigh views herself as weak, small minded, unworthy, pathetic
and powerless against her inner demons, “To
be honest, sometimes I'm not so sure just who I am either.”
pg 134. It seems her only motivation is to get away from her father
and to learn how to love Ian and be loved by him in return, “I
wish I were worthy of his love. (Any love.) I should tell him to run.
But I can't. I need him.” pg
30. Kaeleigh feels that without love she can't really be anyone.
Kaeleigh has some redeeming qualities as well, she is nice and caring
and wants to change how she is and how she reacts to emotional
closeness as well as physical closeness with anyone. Kaeleigh is just
in need of someone to teach her how love is really supposed to be,
not the warped way that her father has taught her, then she could
fight all her inner demons and win instead of the everyday battle and
she has going on inside her head, where every move has to be thought
out and well planned so as not to screw up anything in the coming
days, years, or the rest of her life.
By Jessie
Wow!
ReplyDeleteExcellent and appreciate the work to do two characters. Would have been easy to lose focus with such a difficult analysis but you kept each sketch narrow but detailed.